An interesting debate broke out on Digital point last week that seems
to have continued gathering interest as it moves on. Someone provided a “tip” for “seo newbies” to help build up links for free using appropriate anchor text descriptions.

The tip was, to quote:

“When you’re commenting on other people’s blogs it will usually ask you for 4 things, your name, email, URL and a comment. Be sure to use your keyword anchor text as your name. When your comment is posted, the url you enter will be attached to whatever text you entered in the “Name” field. So instead of putting John in the name field, put My Widgets Rule, or whatever your site’s keywords are. Oh, and try to say something that’s somewhat useful in the comment section, so it doesn’t look like 100% blatant spam.”

Now I must own up and say in the past I have used such techniques but this was before starting this SeoUnique blog. Since then my opinion on this subject has changed. Because the blog world relies so heavily on the community “vibe” I don’t think it’s ethical to use such methods. Of course a lot of blogs carry the NoFollow tag which renders such methods useless anyway but my point is that at the end of the day it’s just rude. Unless a comment that I regard to be of epic standards I will not approve messages from people that use anchor text in their posts.

I’m not a spoil sport and I want everyone to do well in life but if you want to make a comment about a good/bad article you should not expect anything in return.

I have setup a poll to get your opinion on the subject to whether or not you consider this kind of technique ethically right? The results will be interesting, remember be honest!